Health Care’s Rebuke of Reckless Reporting
Posted 4 months ago by Julie Huron
Health Care’s Rebuke of Reckless Reporting
Media Contact: Bryan Black
The health care community stands together to express grave concerns about the recent Bloomberg article, "The Miseducation of America’s Nurse Practitioners." The authors failed to write a balanced story by cherry picking negative information and failing to report the enormous contributions nurse practitioners (NPs) make to patient care and across the health care system.
The authors have omitted the fact that NPs have consistently risen to meet our nation's health care challenges. This includes risking their lives with other health care professionals to treat patients during the pandemic despite a limited supply of personal protective equipment (PPE); setting up mobile clinics or going door to door in disadvantaged communities to provide care; being among the first clinicians to treat patients with opioid use disorder in hundreds of rural counties; and providing care in rural counties, after other clinicians left and hospitals closed, to ensure continued access.
Unfortunately, these types of hit pieces can be written about any profession, but distinctly have no place in our nation’s health care system. This type of journalism not only disparages an honorable profession at a time in which our country is struggling to build our nation’s workforce, but also frightens patients from seeking needed care.
The following points were either provided by AANP or could have been found by the authors if they were seeking to provide readers with any type of balanced article:
- The authors only included one study, which they appeared to discredit by saying it included international NPs. In fact, the authors were provided more than 50 studies that definitively demonstrate that NPs in the United States provide high-quality primary, acute and specialty health care services across the lifespan and in diverse settings.
- Multiple leading health care experts and health policy leaders have evaluated the evidence on NP care and have recommended removing barriers that patients face when seeing NPs. These include the following examples:
- The National Academies of Science, Engineering and Medicine’s report on the future of nursing found that: “Such restrictions limit access to care generally and to the high-quality care offered by APRNs. Those supporting these restrictions maintain that nonphysician providers are less likely to provide high-quality care because they are required to receive less training and clinical experience. However, evidence does not show that scope-of-practice restrictions improve quality of care (Perloff et al., 2019; Yang et al., 2020). Rather, these regulations restrict competition and can contribute to higher health care costs (Adams and Markowitz, 2018; Perloff et al., 2019).” (National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2021. The Future of Nursing 2020-2030: Charting a Path to Achieve Health Equity.)
- The American Enterprise Institute wrote: “Can NPs provide health care of comparable quality to that provided by primary care physicians? Our studies showed that beneficiaries who received their primary care from NPs consistently received significantly higher-quality care than physicians’ patients in several respects. While beneficiaries treated by physicians received slightly better services in a few realms, the differences were marginal. These results held when vulnerable populations of Medicare beneficiaries were analyzed separately and compared to those cared for by physicians, aligning with the findings of many other studies conducted over the past four decades.” (American Enterprise Institute. 2018. Nurse Practitioners: A Solution to America’s Primary Care Crisis.)
- The Brookings Institution wrote: “Opponents contend that quality of care may suffer under the direction of a nonphysician practitioner, citing the shorter length of training and clinical experience required. Their argument is that restrictions are necessary to protect public health. However, academic literature finds no evidence of harm to patients associated with less-restrictive Scope of Practice (SOP) laws. When no harm is present, the restrictions serve only to generate artificial barriers to care that ultimately provide physicians with protection from competition, prevent the attainment of system-wide efficiencies, and constrain overall provider capacity.” (The Hamilton Project. Brookings. 2018. Improving Efficiency in the Health-Care System: Removing Anticompetitive Barriers for Advanced Practice Registered Nurses and Physician Assistants.)
- The National Academies of Science, Engineering and Medicine’s nursing home report found that: “Numerous reviews have identified key outcomes resulting from APRN provided care in nursing homes, including improved management of chronic illnesses, improved functional and health status, improved quality of life, reduced or equivalent mortality and hospital admissions, improved self-care, reduced emergency department use and transfers, lower costs, increased time spent with residents, and increased resident, family, and staff satisfaction.” (National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2022. The National Imperative to Improve Nursing Home Quality: Honoring Our Commitment to Residents, Families, and Staff.)
- NPs typically complete at least six years of formal nursing education and pass national board certification prior to getting licensed and entering practice. NPs enter their graduate degree programs as registered nurses having already completed formal undergraduate Bachelor of Nursing programs, which include clinical rotations. During graduate school, NPs complete academic coursework and additional clinical rotations that prepare them to independently diagnose, manage patient care and prescribe medications and other treatments.
- NP programs are nationally accredited and the national accreditation bodies are held accountable to the U.S. Department of Education (DOE). NPs complete hands-on, supervised patient care clinical rotations that are embedded in their graduate programs and must adhere to accreditation standards. NP students must demonstrate they have integrated this prior knowledge and skill — and do not progress, or graduate, simply based on hours spent in rotation. NPs are required to pass national certification board exams and retain board certification throughout their careers.
- The authors mistake confidence for competence. It’s not unusual for some professionals in any discipline to lack confidence after graduation. For example, a recent survey by the American Academy of Pediatrics found that only 42% of pediatric residents who graduated in 2022 felt prepared for primary care practice, a significant decline from 69% in 2015.
- Citing a fringe medical group as a source, which frequently encourages the disparagement of other health care professions and engages in fear mongering in effort to restrain trade by reducing perceived competition, is reckless.
- In a Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) focus group, patients cited a variety of reasons for choosing an NP or physician associate (PA) as their regular primary care provider, including switching from a physician to an NP or PA as their primary care provider when their physician retired, choosing to see an NP in their practice when they had communication issues with their physician or generally preferring NPs and/or PAs to physicians.
- NPs provide a substantial portion of the high-quality, cost-effective care that communities nationwide require. According to MedPAC, APRNs and PAs comprise approximately one-third of our primary care workforce, and up to half in rural areas. NPs are essential to providing equitable access to care for all communities, including a substantial portion of health care in rural areas and areas of lower socioeconomic and health status.
Generalizations, sensationalism and cherry-picking should not be used by news sources to disparage NPs or other professions that are caring for patients and their families throughout the nation. Taking only individual negative outcomes or perceptions and then generalizing them to an entire profession that cares for patients in over a billion patient visits per year is irresponsible and dangerous. We stand together in rebuking this type of fear mongering by these reporters, Bloomberg News or any group seeking to advance an agenda with these despicable tactics.
Sincerely,
American Association of Nurse Practitioners
American Academy of Emergency Nurse Practitioners
American Academy of Nursing
American Academy of Nurse Practitioners Certification Board
American Association of Colleges of Nursing
American College of Nurse-Midwives
American Nurses Association
American Psychiatric Nurse Association
Commission on Collegiate Nursing Education
Convenient Care Association
Emergency Nurses Association
Gerontological Advanced Practice Nurses Association
National Association of Clinical Nurse Specialists
National Association of Neonatal Nurses
National Association of Neonatal Nurses-Advanced Practice
National Association of Nurse Practitioners in Women’s Health
National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners
National Certification Corporation
National Organization of Nurse Practitioner Faculties
Advanced Practice Nurses of New Jersey
Alaska APRN Alliance
Alaska Nurse Practitioner Association
Arizona Nurse Practitioner Council
Arkansas Nurse Practitioner Association
Association of Nurse Practitioners in Business
Association of Oklahoma Nurse Practitioners
Astera Cancer Care
California Association for Nurse Practitioners
Coalition of Advanced Practices Nurses of Indiana
Connecticut Advanced Practice Registered Nurse Society
Delaware Coalition of Nurse Practitioners
Florida Association of Neonatal Nurse Practitioners
Florida Association of Nurse Practitioners
Florida Chapter of Gerontological Advanced Practice Nurses Association
Florida Coalition of Advanced Practice Nurses
Florida Nurse Practitioners Network
Hart & Arndt Family Health PC
Illinois Society for Advanced Practice Nursing
Jamaica Association of Nurse Practitioners
Kentucky Association of Nurse Practitioners and Nurse-Midwives
Maine NP Association
Maryland Academy of Advanced Practice Clinicians
Massachusetts Coalition of Nurse Practitioners
Michigan Council of Nurse Practitioners
Minnesota Nurse Practitioners
Mississippi Association of Nurse Practitioners
Missouri APRN Full Practice Authority
New Hampshire Nurse Practitioner Association
New Jersey Palliative Care Advanced Practice Nurse Consortium
New Mexico Nurse Practitioner Council
Northern New Jersey Hospice and Palliative Nurse Association
North Alabama Nurse Practitioner Association
North Texas Nurse Practitioners
NP’s of Lee County
Nurse Practitioner Alliance of Alabama
Nurse Practitioner Alliance of Rhode Island
Nurse Practitioner Association New York State
Nurse Practitioner Association of Long Island
Nurse Practitioner Association of Maryland
Nurse Practitioner Council of Miami-Dade Inc.
Nurse Practitioners of Idaho
Nurse Practitioners of New York
Nurse Practitioners of Oregon
Ohio Association of Advanced Practice Nurses
Oasis Health Partners
Oregon Nurses Association
Patients First Medical Clinic
Pennsylvania Coalition of Nurse Practitioners
Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital
Society of Psychiatric Advanced Practice Nurses
South Florida Council of Advanced Practice Nurses
Tampa Bay Advanced Practice Nurses Council
Tennessee Nurse Practitioner Association
Texas Nurse Practitioners
United Advance Registered Nurses
Utah Nurse Practitioners Association
Vermont Nurse Practitioner Association
Virginia Council of Nurse Practitioners
West Virginia Nurses Association
###
The American Association of Nurse Practitioners® (AANP) is the largest professional membership organization for nurse practitioners (NPs) of all specialties. It represents the interests of the more than 385,000 licensed NPs in the U.S. AANP provides legislative leadership at the local, state and national levels, advancing health policy; promoting excellence in practice, education and research; and establishing standards that best serve NPs' patients and other health care consumers. As The Voice of the Nurse Practitioner®, AANP represents the interests of NPs as providers of high-quality, cost-effective, comprehensive, patient-centered health care. To locate an NP in your community, visit npfinder.com. For more information about NPs, visit aanp.org.